I've tried other brands and I've even tried making the spread myself (but from cheap cookies since I like the cookies too much to experiment with them) but this is among the top. I wonder if it really is the original? I'll update this post to include brands I like and don't like.
Cookie Butter Spread list:
Good
Lotus (pictured above)
Trader Joe's (photo from their website)
Meh
Goya
St. Nicholas (photo from Flickr)